DNE
(See PDF for image) STATE OF WISCONSIN
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
J.B. VAN HOLLEN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
Raymond P. Taffora
Deputy Attorney General
114 East, State Capitol
P.O. Box 7857
Madison, WI 53707-7857
608/266-1221
TTY 1-800-947-3529
January 28, 2010 OAG—01—10
Mr. Dennis E. Kenealy
Corporation Counsel
Ozaukee County
Post Office Box 994
Port Washington, WI 53074-0994
Dear Mr. Kenealy:
¶ 1.
You indicate that the Ozaukee County Administrator currently appoints all prospective members of the boards and commissions of Ozaukee County. All such appointments are confirmed by the Ozaukee County Board. A proposed county board resolution would require that all county board members who are prospective appointees to county boards and commissions be appointed by the chairperson of the county board rather than by the county administrator. Such appointments would remain subject to confirmation by the county board. You advise that the county administrator supports the proposed resolution out of concern that “his naming of county board members will alienate some board members who may have applied for the position[s], thus jeopardizing his effectiveness and potentially his job.” You note that the proposed resolution may be in conflict with Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2)(c), which provides that the county administrator “[a]ppoint[s] the members of all boards and commissions where the statutes provide that such appointments shall be made by the county board or by the chairperson of the county board.” A similar provision, Wis. Stat. § 59.17(2)(c), applies to appointments to boards and commissions by elected county executives.QUESTION PRESENTED AND BRIEF ANSWER
¶ 2.
You ask whether a county board in a county with a county administrator or a county executive can exercise its home rule authority so as to enact a resolution requiring that all county board members who are prospective appointees to all county boards and commissions be appointed by the chairperson of the county board rather than by the county administrator.¶ 3.
In my opinion, a county board in a county with a county administrator or a county executive cannot reassign the power of appointment that is statutorily granted to a county executive or a county administrator in cases where the statutes provide that appointments to a particular board or commission are to be made by the county board, by the chairperson of the county board, or by the county administrator or county executive.ANALYSIS
¶ 4.
Wisconsin Const. art. IV, § 22 provides that “[t]he legislature may confer upon the boards of supervisors of the several counties of the state such powers of a local, legislative and administrative character as they shall from time to time prescribe.” A county is a creature of the legislature and as such, it has only those powers that the legislature by statute provided. Wis. Const, art. IV, § 22. For more than a century, Wisconsin courts consistently have interpreted counties’ powers as arising solely from the statutes[.]
¶ 6.
As a direct consequence of the fact that all county powers must be derived from a statutory source, “[a] county’s home rule power is more limited than the home rule power that is afforded to cities . . . .” Jackson County, 293 Wis. 2d 497, ¶ 17.¶ 7.
Selecting or appointing an individual to perform a particular task or function in this context is an organizational or administrative power. See Harbick v. Marinette County, 138 Wis. 2d 172, 176‑77, 405 N.W.2d 724 (Ct. App. 1987). Wisconsin Stat. § 59.51(1), which speaks directly to a county board’s administrative and organizational powers, provides:The board of each county shall have the authority to exercise any organizational or administrative power, subject only to the constitution and any enactment of the legislature which grants the organizational or administrative power to a county executive or county administrator or to a person supervised by a county executive or county administrator or any enactment which is of statewide concern and which uniformly affects every county. Any organizational or administrative power conferred under this subchapter shall be in addition to all other grants. A county board may exercise any organizational or administrative power under this subchapter without limitation because of enumeration, and these powers shall be broadly and liberally construed and limited only by express language.
¶ 8.
Among the legislative enactments granting organizational or administrative powers to a county administrator is the power to “[a]ppoint the members of all boards and commissions where the statutes provide that such appointment shall be made by the county board or by the chairperson of the county board.” Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2)(c). A county administrator’s appointments under this provision are subject to the county board’s approval. Id.¶ 9.
In a county that has elected to create the office of county administrator, the appointment power conferred upon a county administrator is exclusive. Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2) (providing that the “duties and powers of the county administrator shall be . . . to” appoint such members of boards and commissions as provided in Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2)(c)). The word “shall” is presumed to be mandatory. See Fond du Lac County v. Elizabeth M.P., 2003 WI App 232, ¶ 21, 267 Wis. 2d 739, 672 N.W.2d 88. Nothing in the language or context of the relevant statutes indicates a reason to depart from this presumption. The statutory scheme involves a mandatory or exclusive power to appoint, as the appointment power conferred on a county administrator by Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2)(c) expressly involves appointments that the laws would otherwise vest in the county board or county board chairperson.¶ 10.
Moreover, the interpretation that a county administrator’s power to appoint is mandatory and exclusive in this context is strengthened by the fact that the Legislature has provided counties of populations under 500,000 with the option of creating the position of administrative coordinator in lieu of having a county administrator. Wis. Stat. § 59.19. Like county administrators, administrative coordinators are responsible for “coordinating all administrative and management functions of the county government not otherwise vested by law in boards or commissions, or in other elected officers.” Id. Administrative coordinators are not, however, provided by statute with appointment powers. Compare Wis. Stat. § 59.19 (enumerating administrative coordinator duties) with Wis. Stat. § 59.18(2) (enumerating county administrator duties).¶ 11.
Because the “[s]tatutory powers and duties conferred upon a county officer cannot be narrowed, enlarged, or taken away by a county board . . .,” Harbick, 138 Wis. 2d at 179, a county board in a county with a county administrator cannot reassign a county administrator’s statutory appointment duties to the chairperson of the county board.
