This is the preview version of the Wisconsin State Legislature site.
Please see http://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov for the production version.
Tax 11.87 Note6) Grocery Store A has a self-service salad bar. Grocery Store A’s sales of prepared foods, based on its prior tax year, are less than 75% of its total sales of food and food ingredients. The plates necessary to receive the food items at the salad bar, along with the forks, knives, and napkins are made available to the purchaser. Grocery Store A’s sales of the self-service salad bar items are subject to tax since the plates necessary to receive the food items at the salad bar are made available to the purchaser.
Tax 11.87(2)(d)(d) Caterers. Food and food ingredients, sold by caterers are generally taxable as prepared foods. For purposes of this paragraph:
Tax 11.87(2)(d)1.1. “Caterer” means a person engaged in the business of preparing meals, food, and drinks, and serving these items on premises designated by a purchaser. When an agreement with a caterer provides that the caterer shall prepare and serve “prepared foods” either for a stated price per meal, for a lump sum, or for a price per plate, the consideration paid shall constitute taxable receipts.
Tax 11.87(2)(d)2.2. Charges made by a caterer for preparing and serving prepared foods to social clubs, service clubs, fraternal organizations, or other nonexempt purchasers shall constitute exempt sales for resale only if the purchasers are regularly engaged as retailers of prepared foods, hold a seller’s permit and give a properly completed exemption certificate to the caterer.
Tax 11.87(2)(d)3.3. The tax shall apply to items purchased by caterers, including dishes, silverware, linen napkins, tablecloths, punch fountains, coffee silver service, and glassware, which are used by caterers to serve food or beverages to their customers, or used in conjunction with providing catering service, unless customers are charged a separate and optional amount for their use. In addition, items such as tents, public address systems, portable dance floors, portable bars, chairs, and tables may be purchased without tax for resale, if used exclusively for rental purposes by a caterer and if customers are charged a separate and optional amount for their use. Disposable items transferred to customers for a valuable consideration, including paper and plastic cups and plates, plastic eating utensils, napkins, straws, placemats, and toothpicks also may be purchased without tax for resale.
Tax 11.87(2)(e)(e) Vending machine sales. A vending machine operator’s receipts from candy, dietary supplements, prepared foods, and soft drinks are taxable.
Tax 11.87(2)(f)(f) Cover and minimum charges. Cover charges or minimum charges, whether listed separately on a bill or collected as an admission fee or fixed charge, which entitle the patron to receive entertainment or to dance as well as to receive prepared food, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, or other taxable property, items, or goods, shall be taxable. If prepared food, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, or other taxable property, items, or goods are furnished, prepared, or served at locations other than the place of business of the seller or in a room other than a regular dining room and an extra charge is made for the service, the entire amount shall be taxable.
Tax 11.87(2)(g)(g) Tips.
Tax 11.87(2)(g)1.1. A tip which is given directly to an employee in cash or which is added by a customer to a bill which amount is then turned over in full to the employee shall be exempt from the sales tax, if the amount of the tip is wholly in the discretion or judgment of the customer and the customer does not make the payment pursuant to an arrangement made with the seller.
Tax 11.87(2)(g)2.2. A flat amount or flat percentage, whether designated as a tip or as a service charge, that is added to the price of prepared food or other taxable food or food ingredient under a requirement of the seller or an arrangement made with the seller is a part of the sales price of the prepared food or other taxable food or food ingredient and shall be subject to the tax, regardless of whether the amount or flat percentage may be subsequently paid over in whole or in part by the seller to employees.
Tax 11.87(2)(h)(h) Huber law meals. Prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks sold to “Huber Law” prisoners by a sheriff or a governmental unit shall be subject to the tax.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)(i) Food and food ingredients to employees. Sales of prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks to employees by an employer for a consideration shall be taxable. For purposes of this paragraph:
Tax 11.87(2)(i)1.1. A consideration shall be deemed made for prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks if any one of the following conditions is met:
Tax 11.87(2)(i)1.a.a. The employee pays cash for the prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks consumed.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)1.b.b. An actual, specific charge for the prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks is deducted from an employee’s wages.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)1.c.c. An employee receives the prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks in lieu of cash to bring the employee’s compensation up to the legal minimum wage.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)1.d.d. An employee has the option to receive cash for the prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks not consumed.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)2.2. In the absence of any of the conditions in subd. 1., a consideration is not deemed made when:
Tax 11.87(2)(i)2.a.a. A value is assigned to prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks only as a means of reporting the fair market value of an employee’s prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks for FICA, social security, or union contract purposes.
Tax 11.87(2)(i)2.b.b. An employee who does not consume available prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, and soft drinks has no recourse against the employer for additional cash wages.
Tax 11.87(2)(j)(j) Transportation companies. The sale of prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, and alcoholic beverages by transportation companies, such as airlines or railways, to a customer while operating in Wisconsin for a specific charge shall be taxable. These prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, and alcoholic beverages may be purchased by the transportation companies without tax for resale. However, if the sales price of the prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, or alcoholic beverages is not separately stated to the customer, the tax shall apply to purchases of these prepared foods, candy, dietary supplements, soft drinks, and alcoholic beverages by transportation companies.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)(k) Organizations and their members.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)1.1. When members of an exempt or nonexempt organization meet at a hotel, restaurant, or other place of business where food or drinks are sold and the members pay for the items, the place of business shall be considered selling directly to the members and not to the organization except as provided in subds. 2. and 3. The sales shall, therefore, be subject to the tax, even if the organization collects from the members, pays the seller, and retains a portion of the collections for its own purposes. In these situations, the organization shall be deemed acting for its members’ convenience and not purchasing and reselling prepared foods.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)2.2. When an exempt organization as described in s. 77.54 (9a) (f), Stats., pays for food and beverages out of its own funds and provides the items to members or others without charge, the sale of the items by a retailer to the organization is not subject to the tax. If the exempt organization holds a certificate of exempt status issued by the department, it shall give the retailer the certificate number to claim the exemption.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)3.3. Sales of food and beverages are not subject to tax even though the employee of an exempt organization as described in s. 77.54 (9a) (f), Stats., pays for the sale of the food or beverages provided all of the following are met:
Tax 11.87(2)(k)3.a.a. The retailer issues the billing or invoice for the food and beverages in the name of the exempt organization.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)3.b.b. The certificate of exempt status number of the exempt organization is entered on the retailer’s copy of the invoice or billing document.
Tax 11.87(2)(k)3.c.c. The retailer keeps a copy of the documents described in subd. 3. a. and b.
Tax 11.87(3)(3)Exempt sales. The following food and food ingredients shall be exempt:
Tax 11.87(3)(a)(a) Health care facilities. Food and food ingredients, except soft drinks, fermented malt beverages, and intoxicating liquor, sold by hospitals, sanatoriums, nursing homes, retirement homes, community-based residential facilities as defined in s. 50.01 (1g), Stats., or any facility certified or licensed under ch. 48, Stats. However, if an affiliated organization sells the items, the exemption does not apply.
Tax 11.87 NoteExample: If a ladies’ auxiliary of a hospital, separate from the hospital, operates a coffee shop on the hospital premises, although the ladies’ auxiliary is a nonprofit organization, the prepared food and drinks sold at the coffee shop are taxable.
Tax 11.87(3)(b)(b) “Meals on wheels.” Prepared food sold to the elderly or disabled by persons providing “mobile meals on wheels.”
Tax 11.87(3)(c)(c) Institutions of higher education. Food and food ingredients furnished in accordance with any contract or agreement or paid for to such institution through the use of an account of such institution, by a public or private institution of higher education to any of the following:
Tax 11.87(3)(c)1.1. An undergraduate student, a graduate student, or a student enrolled in a professional school if the student is enrolled for credit at the public or private institution of higher education and if the food and food ingredients are consumed by the student.
Tax 11.87(3)(c)2.2. A national football league team.
Tax 11.87(3)(d)(d) Groceries. Sales of food and food ingredients, except candy, dietary supplements, prepared foods, and soft drinks are exempt from tax under s. 77.54 (20n), Stats. This includes sales of prepackaged ice cream, ice milk, or sherbet in any size container and also of ice cream, ice milk, sherbet, or yogurt as cones, sundaes, sodas and shakes.
Tax 11.87 NoteNote: See s. Tax 11.51 for more information.
Tax 11.87(3)(e)(e) Supervised boarding facilities. The portion of the monthly fee charged by a supervised boarding facility for low income adults who are receiving or are eligible for social security, supplemental security income, veterans administration, or other disability and retirement benefits reflecting the value of prepared foods provided.
Tax 11.87(3)(f)(f) Food and food ingredients to employees. Purchases by restaurants of candy, soft drinks, dietary supplements, prepared foods, and disposable products that are transferred with such items, are exempt from sales and use tax if the restaurant transfers such items to its employees during the employee’s work hours for no consideration.
Tax 11.87(3)(g)(g) Vegetable oil and animal fat. Sales of vegetable oil and animal fat to an individual that will be converted to motor vehicle fuel for use in that individual’s personal motor vehicle if the individual does not sell any of that fuel during the year. This exemption only applies if the motor vehicle fuel is exempt from the motor vehicle fuel tax under s. 78.01 (1), Stats.
Tax 11.87(3)(h)(h) Prepared food manufactured by the retailer. Sales of prepared food that is manufactured at one location and sold by the same retailer at a different location, are exempt if all of the following apply:
Tax 11.87(3)(h)1.1. The prepared food is not candy, a soft drink, or a dietary supplement.
Tax 11.87(3)(h)2.2. The prepared food is manufactured by the retailer at a building assessed as manufacturing property under s. 70.995, Stats., or that would be assessed as manufacturing property under s. 70.995, Stats., if the building was located in Wisconsin.
Tax 11.87(3)(h)3.3. The retailer does not make any retail sales of prepared food at the building described in subd. 2.
Tax 11.87(3)(h)4.4. Either of the following apply:
Tax 11.87(3)(h)4.a.a. The prepared food is sold by the retailer in a frozen state without eating utensils (i.e., plates, bowls, knives, forks, spoons, glasses, cups, napkins, straws).
Tax 11.87(3)(h)4.b.b. The prepared food consists of more than 50% yogurt.
Tax 11.87(4)(4)Specialty situations.
Tax 11.87(4)(a)(a) Specialty items. A seller engaged principally in the sale of taxable food may also be engaged in the sale of exempt food.
Tax 11.87 NoteExample: A restaurant which specializes in serving pancakes may also sell containers of its specially prepared syrup to take home. Sales of this syrup are not taxable.
Tax 11.87(4)(b)(b) Fund-raising events. When a charge to a customer bears little or no relationship to the actual value of taxable food and food ingredients and beverages received, the tax shall be based on the reasonable value of the taxable food and food ingredients and other tangible personal property, items, property, and goods under s. 77.52 (1) (b), (c), and (d), Stats., and taxable services received by the customer. The retailer is responsible for determining the reasonable value and showing that the charge to the patron bears little or no relationship to the actual value received.
Tax 11.87 NoteExamples: 1) Company A puts on a fundraising dinner. Individuals wishing to attend the dinner must pay $300 per person to attend. The actual value of the dinner received is $50. Company A may compute the tax that must be remitted on the $50 since that is the actual value of the dinner received. The actual value in this example is based on the amount that an individual would be required to pay for this dinner if it was not a fundraising dinner.
Tax 11.87 Note2) Company B puts on a fundraising dinner and dance. Individuals wishing to attend the dinner and dance must pay $300 per person to attend. The actual value of the dinner received is $50 and the actual value of admission to the dance is $25. Company B may compute the tax that must be remitted on the $75 since that is the actual value of the dinner and admission to the dance that is received. The actual values in this example are based on the amount that an individual would be required to pay for the dinner and to attend the dance if this was not a fundraising dinner and dance.
Tax 11.87 NoteNote: Section Tax 11.87 interprets ss. 77.51 (10m), (12m), (14) (b) and (f), and (15b), and 77.54 (20n) and (20r), Stats.
Tax 11.87 NoteNote: The interpretations in s. Tax 11.87 are effective under the general sales and use tax law on and after September 1, 1969, except: (a) Sales of meals by retirement homes became exempt April 25, 1978, pursuant to Chapter 250, Laws of 1977; (b) Sales of meals by certain health care facilities off their premises became taxable October 1, 1991, pursuant to 1991 Wis. Act 39; (c) Sales of meals by community-based residential facilities on their premises became exempt June 1, 1994, pursuant to 1993 Wis. Act. 332; (d) The exemption for certain meals, food, food products and beverages furnished by institutions of higher education was revised to apply only if the items are furnished to an undergraduate student, a graduate student or a student enrolled in a professional school if the student is enrolled for credit at that institution and if the items are consumed by that student, or the items are furnished to a national football league team, effective for contracts or agreements entered into on or after October 14, 1997, pursuant to 1997 Wis. Act 27, and further revised to include certain meals, food, food products or beverages paid for to an institution of higher education through the use of an account of the institution, if the items are furnished by the institution, effective December 31, 1997, pursuant to 1997 Wis. Act 41; (e) Sales of certain food combinations became exempt effective August 1, 1997, pursuant to 1997 Wis. Act 237; (f) The exemption for food and food ingredients was revised to exempt all food and food ingredients except candy, dietary supplements, prepared food and soft drinks effective October 1, 2009, pursuant to 2009 Wis. Act 2; (g) The change of the term “gross receipts” to “sales price” and the separate impositions of tax on coins and stamps sold above face value under s. 77.52 (1) (b), Stats., certain leased property affixed to real property under s. 77.52 (1) (c), Stats., and digital goods under s. 77.52 (1) (d), Stats., became effective October 1, 2009, pursuant to 2009 Wis. Act 2; and (h) The exemption for prepared food manufactured and sold by the same retailer under s. 77.54 (20n) (d), Stats., became effective September 23, 2017, pursuant to 2017 Wis. Act 59.
Tax 11.87 HistoryHistory: Cr. Register, March, 1978, No. 267, eff. 4-1-78; renum. (1) (b) to be (1) (g), cr. (1) (b) to (f), am. (3) (a), (b) and (c), Register, January, 1983, No. 325, eff. 2-1-83; am. (2) (d) 3., (g) and (i), Register, June, 1983, No. 330, eff. 7-1-83; am. (3) (d), Register, September, 1984, No. 345, eff. 10-1-84; correction in (1) (b) made under s. 13.93 (2m) (b) 7., Stats; am. (1) (intro.) and (f), (2) (a), (b), (c), (d) 1., (g), (j) and (k), (3) (a) and (4) (a), cr. (2) (k) 3., Register, June, 1991, No. 426, eff. 7-1-91; am. (2) (d) (intro.), 3., (f), (i) (intro.), 1. intro. and 2. intro., (k) 2., (3) (a), (b) and (d), cr. (3) (e), Register, December, 1992, No. 444, eff. 1-1-93; renum. (1) (a) to (g) to be (b) to (h) and am. (1) (b), cr. (1) (a), am. (3) (a), (d) and (e), Register, December, 1996, No. 492, eff. 1-1-97; am. (1) (b), (2) (c) and (3) (a), renum. (1) (e) and (f) to be (1) (f) and (e), r. and recr. (3) (c), Register, October, 1999, No. 526, eff. 11-1-99; EmR0924: emerg. am. (title), (1) (b), (e), (h), (2) (a), (b), (d), (f), (g) 2., (h) to (k) 1., (3) (intro.), (a), (b), (c) 1., 2., (d), (e) and (4) (b), cr. (1) (em) and (3) (f), r. and recr. (2) (c), (e) and (3) (c) (intro.), eff. 10-1-09; CR 09-090: am. (title), (1) (b), (e), (h), (2) (a), (b), (d), (f), (g) 2., (h) to (k) 1., (3) (intro.), (a), (b), (c) 1., 2., (d), (e) and (4) (b), cr. (1) (em) and (3) (f), r. and recr. (2) (c), (e) and (3) (c) (intro.) Register May 2010 No. 653, eff. 6-1-10; CR 10-094: am. (2) (a), (j), (3) (a) Register November 2010 No. 659, eff. 12-1-10; CR 12-014: cr. (3) (g), am. (4) (b), cr. (4) (b) (Examples) Register August 2012 No. 680, eff. 9-1-12; CR 19-122: am. (3) (b) Register July 2020 No. 775, eff. 8-1-20; CR 20-018: cr. (3) (h) Register July 2021 No. 787, eff. 8-1-21.
Tax 11.88Tax 11.88Manufactured homes, mobile homes, modular homes, and recreational vehicles.
Tax 11.88(1)(1)Definitions. For purposes of this section:
Tax 11.88(1)(a)1.1. “Manufactured home,” as defined in s. 101.91 (2), Stats., means either of the following:
Tax 11.88(1)(a)1.a.a. A structure that is designed to be used as a dwelling with or without a permanent foundation and that is certified by the federal department of housing and urban development as complying with the standards established under 42 USC 5401 to 5425.
Tax 11.88(1)(a)1.b.b. A mobile home, unless a mobile home is specifically excluded under the applicable statute.
Tax 11.88(1)(a)2.2. As provided in 42 USC 5402 (6), “manufactured home” means a structure, transportable in one or more sections, which, in the traveling mode, is eight body feet or more in width or forty body feet or more in length, or, when erected on site, is three hundred twenty or more square feet, and which is built on a permanent chassis and designed to be used as a dwelling with or without a permanent foundation when connected to the required utilities, and includes the plumbing, heating, air-conditioning, and electrical systems contained therein; except that such term shall include any structure which meets all the requirements of this paragraph except the size requirements and with respect to which the manufacturer voluntarily files a certification required by the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and complies with the standards established under this chapter; and except that such term shall not include any self-propelled recreational vehicle.
Tax 11.88(1)(b)(b) “Mobile home,” as defined in s. 101.91 (10), Stats., means a vehicle manufactured or assembled before June 15, 1976, designed to be towed as a single unit or in sections upon a highway by a motor vehicle and equipped and used, or intended to be used, primarily for human habitation, with walls of rigid uncollapsible construction, which has an overall length in excess of 45 feet. “Mobile home” includes the mobile home structure, its plumbing, heating, air conditioning and electrical systems, and all appliances and all other equipment carrying a manufacturer’s warranty.
Tax 11.88(1)(bm)1.1. “Modular home,” as defined in s. 101.71 (6), Stats., means any structure or component thereof which is intended for use as a dwelling and satisfies either of the following conditions:
Tax 11.88(1)(bm)1.a.a. The structure or component is of closed construction and fabricated or assembled on-site or off-site in manufacturing facilities for installation, connection, or assembly and installation, at the building site. In this subd. 1. a., “closed construction” has the meaning given in s. 101.71 (1), Stats.
Tax 11.88(1)(bm)1.b.b. The structure or component is a building of open construction which is made or assembled in manufacturing facilities away from the building site for installation, connection, or assembly and installation, on the building site and for which certification is sought by the manufacturer. In this subd. 1. b. and subd. 2., “open construction” has the meaning given in s. 101.71 (7), Stats.
Tax 11.88(1)(bm)2.2. “Modular home” does not mean any manufactured home under s. 101.91, Stats., or any building of open construction which is not subject to subd. 1. b.
Tax 11.88(1)(c)(c) “New manufactured home,” as defined in s. 101.91 (11), Stats., means a manufactured home that has never been occupied, used or sold for personal or business use.
Tax 11.88(1)(d)(d) “New recreational vehicle,” as defined in s. 218.10 (7), Stats., means a recreational vehicle which has never been occupied, used or sold for personal or business use.
Tax 11.88(1)(e)(e) “Recreational vehicle,” as defined in s. 340.01 (48r), Stats., means a vehicle that is designed to be towed upon a highway by a motor vehicle, that is equipped and used, or intended to be used, primarily for temporary or recreational human habitation, that has walls of rigid construction, and that does not exceed 45 feet in length.
Tax 11.88(1)(f)(f) “Recreational vehicle dealer” has the meaning given in s. 218.10 (1g), Stats.
Tax 11.88(1)(g)(g) “Retailer” is a person who has or is required to have a certificate under s. 77.52 (7), Stats., or s. 77.53 (9), Stats., and who holds or is required to hold a permit issued under s. 77.52 (9), Stats., or s. 77.53 (9m), Stats.
Tax 11.88(1)(h)(h) “Used manufactured home,” as defined in s. 101.91 (12), Stats., means a manufactured home that has previously been occupied, used or sold for personal or business use.
Tax 11.88(1)(i)(i) “Used recreational vehicle” has the meaning given in s. 218.10 (9), Stats.
Tax 11.88(2)(2)Manufactured and Mobile homes as personal property vs. realty improvement. A manufactured or mobile home is personal property if it is located in a manufactured home community, a mobile home park, or other place where the land on which the manufactured or mobile home is located is not owned by the manufactured or mobile home owner. A manufactured or mobile home is a realty improvement if it is permanently affixed to land owned by the owner of the manufactured or mobile home. It is permanently affixed to the land for sales tax purposes if the manufactured or mobile home sits on a foundation and is connected to utilities. “On a foundation” means it is off the wheels and sitting on some other support.
Tax 11.88(3)(3)Sales of manufactured and mobile homes which are realty improvements.
Tax 11.88(3)(a)(a) The sale of a manufactured or mobile home and the land to which it is permanently affixed is the sale of a realty improvement not subject to the tax. The sale of a manufactured or mobile home which is a realty improvement on the land of the seller, and which is acquired by the purchaser for removal from the seller’s land for permanent attachment to the purchaser’s land, is the sale of realty.
Tax 11.88(3)(b)(b) If the seller of a manufactured or mobile home as part of the sales transaction agrees to permanently affix the home on a foundation on land owned by the purchaser, the seller is a contractor-consumer engaged in improving realty. Except as provided in par. (c), sales of manufactured or mobile homes to the contractor-consumer are subject to the tax, but the sales price from the subsequent sale by the contractor-consumer to the purchaser of the home are not taxable.
Tax 11.88(3)(c)(c) Sales of manufactured homes to the contractor-consumer for use in real property construction activities outside Wisconsin are exempt from Wisconsin sales and use tax.
Tax 11.88(4)(4)Sales and rentals of manufactured and mobile homes which are personal property.
Tax 11.88(4)(a)(a) Under s. 77.54 (31), Stats., the total sales price from the sale of a used mobile home or a used manufactured home is exempt from the sales and use tax.
Tax 11.88(4)(b)(b) Under s. 77.51 (15b) (b) 7. and (12m) (b) 7., Stats., 35% of the total sales price from the sale of a new manufactured home is exempt from the tax. No credit is allowed for trade-in allowances on the purchase of these new manufactured homes.
Tax 11.88(4)(c)(c) Under s. 77.54 (36), Stats., the rental of a mobile home or a manufactured home used for residence for a continuous period of one month or more is exempt from the sales and use tax, whether the manufactured or mobile home is classified as real or personal property.
Tax 11.88(4)(d)(d) Under s. 77.54 (7), Stats., recreational vehicles, as defined in s. 340.01 (48r), Stats., registered or titled or required to be registered or titled in this state that are transferred to the child, spouse, parent, father-in-law, mother-in-law, son-in-law, or daughter-in-law of the transferor are exempt occasional sales if the recreational vehicle, as defined in s. 340.01 (48r), Stats., has been previously registered or titled in Wisconsin in the name of the transferor and the transferor is not engaged in the business of selling recreational vehicles, as defined in s. 340.01 (48r), Stats.
Tax 11.88(4)(e)(e) Under s. 77.53 (18), Stats., the use tax does not apply to a manufactured home or mobile home purchased by a nonresident outside Wisconsin 90 days or more before bringing the manufactured or mobile home into Wisconsin in connection with a change of domicile to Wisconsin.
Tax 11.88(4m)(4m)Modular homes.
Tax 11.88(4m)(a)(a) The sale of a modular home and the land to which it is permanently affixed is the sale of a realty improvement not subject to the tax.
Loading...
Loading...
Published under s. 35.93, Stats. Updated on the first day of each month. Entire code is always current. The Register date on each page is the date the chapter was last published.