Register June 2006 No. 606
Chapter NR 119
PHOSPHORUS SITE-SPECIFIC WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
NR 119.03 Less stringent SSC. NR 119.04 More stringent SSC. NR 119.05 Methods for determining an SSC. NR 119.06 Minimum requirements for an SSC submittal. NR 119.07 Decision regarding SSC request. NR 119.01NR 119.01 General. This chapter establishes standard protocols for developing site-specific water quality criteria for total phosphorus. A phosphorus site-specific criterion may be established to appropriately protect a waterbody’s designated uses when the applicable statewide total phosphorus criterion, as specified in s. NR 102.06, is determined by the department to be more or less stringent than necessary to protect the uses of the waterbody due to site-specific conditions. The requirements specified in s. 281.15 (1) and (2) (b) to (e), Stats., shall be met when developing a site-specific criterion under this chapter. Protection of a waterbody’s designated uses is evaluated using indicators of the ecosystem’s response to phosphorus and overall biotic integrity. After a phosphorus site-specific criterion is adopted, approved by the U.S. EPA, and takes effect, it becomes the applicable water quality criterion under s. 281.15, Stats., for the approved waterbody or segment. NR 119.01 HistoryHistory: CR 19-093: cr. Register September 2022 No. 801, eff. 10-1-22. NR 119.02NR 119.02 Definitions. In this chapter the following definitions apply: NR 119.02 NoteNote: Biological assessment thresholds are specified in subch. III of ch. NR 102. NR 119.02(2)(2) “Clean Water Act” or “CWA” means the federal Clean Water Act of 1972 and amendments. NR 119.02(3)(3) “Designated use” means a use assigned to Wisconsin’s waterbodies as specified in s. NR 102.04. NR 119.02 NoteNote: Pursuant to the Clean Water Act, all of Wisconsin’s surface waters are assigned to the following use categories: aquatic life, recreation, public health and welfare, wildlife.
NR 119.02(4)(4) “Less stringent SSC” means a site-specific phosphorus criterion that is established at a concentration higher than a waterbody’s statewide phosphorus criterion. NR 119.02(5)(5) “More stringent SSC” means a site-specific phosphorus criterion that is established at a concentration lower than a waterbody’s statewide phosphorus criterion. NR 119.02(6)(6) “Natural background phosphorus concentration” means the phosphorus concentration from natural sources, including forested and undeveloped lands, and from natural processes such as weathering and dissolution, that would exist in the absence of measurable impacts from human activity or influence. NR 119.02(7)(7) “Phosphorus response indicator” means an indicator and its thresholds, as specified in s. NR 102.60 (2) to (4), that characterize the condition or abundance of aquatic organisms that are responsive to phosphorus. NR 119.02(8)(8) “Section 303(d) list” means a list of waters that do not attain water quality standards and require a total maximum daily load analysis, as specified in Section 303(d) of the Clean Water Act. NR 119.02(9)(9) “Site-specific criterion” or “SSC” means a phosphorus criterion applicable to a waterbody or segment that differs from the statewide phosphorus criterion due to specific conditions at the waterbody or segment, documented using data for the specific site or a similar reference site. NR 119.02(10)(10) “Statewide phosphorus criterion” means the statewide phosphorus surface water quality criterion specified in s. NR 102.06 that applies to a specific waterbody in absence of an adopted, approved, and effective site-specific criterion. NR 119.02(11)(11) “Strahler stream order” is a numerical hierarchy of stream segments increasing from headwaters through downstream reaches. NR 119.02(13)(13) “U.S. EPA” means the United States environmental protection agency. NR 119.02(15)(15) “WPDES permit” means a Wisconsin pollutant discharge elimination system permit issued by the department under ch. 283, Stats. NR 119.02 HistoryHistory: CR 19-093: cr. Register September 2022 No. 801, eff. 10-1-22. NR 119.03NR 119.03 Less stringent SSC. A waterbody or segment may be eligible for a less stringent SSC if the requestor demonstrates and the department determines that the designated uses of the waterbody and its affected downstream waters can be protected by a less stringent phosphorus criterion based on the analysis of site-specific data. For the department to approve a less stringent SSC, the SSC shall be developed using methods specified in ss. NR 119.05 to 119.06 and be protective of downstream uses as specified in s. NR 119.06 (6). The categories of waterbodies that may qualify for less stringent SSC include all of the following: NR 119.03(1)(1) Biological metrics attained. A less stringent SSC may be appropriate for a waterbody that is not attaining its statewide phosphorus criterion if all of its phosphorus response indicators and biological assessment thresholds are attained. NR 119.03(2)(2) Biological metrics not attained. A less stringent SSC may be appropriate for a waterbody that is not attaining its statewide phosphorus criterion even if one or more of its phosphorus response indicators or biological assessment thresholds are not attained, provided a modeling analysis demonstrates that the phosphorus response indicators are expected to be attained if the waterbody’s phosphorus concentration is sufficiently reduced to attain a proposed SSC that is less stringent than the statewide phosphorus criterion. NR 119.03 NoteNote: Certain reservoirs with a statewide phosphorus criterion of 30-40 ug/L may fit in this category. An example of this analysis is the modeling and analysis conducted for Petenwell and Castle Rock Lakes.
NR 119.03(3)(3) High natural background phosphorus concentration. A less stringent SSC may be appropriate if a waterbody is not attaining the statewide phosphorus criterion because the natural background phosphorus concentration is higher than the statewide phosphorus criterion. NR 119.03 HistoryHistory: CR 19-093: cr. Register September 2022 No. 801, eff. 10-1-22. NR 119.04NR 119.04 More stringent SSC. A waterbody or segment is eligible for a more stringent SSC if the requestor demonstrates and the department determines that the statewide phosphorus criterion is not sufficiently protective of the waterbody’s designated uses. A more stringent SSC may be appropriate if a waterbody is in one of the following categories: NR 119.04(1)(1) Biological metrics not attained. A more stringent SSC may be appropriate if a waterbody attains its statewide phosphorus criterion but does not attain one or more of its phosphorus response indicators or biological assessment thresholds. However, a more stringent SSC is not appropriate under this subsection if a biological assessment threshold or phosphorus response indicator is not attained due to factors other than phosphorus, and the department determines that phosphorus is not contributing to the nonattainment. NR 119.04 NoteNote: Because flowing waters may transport algae downstream from where it is produced, an SSC should only be established on the segment of the waterbody where the impairment is being generated. For example, if a river directly downstream of an impoundment attains its phosphorus criterion but receives high algae concentrations passed through from the impounded area, a more stringent SSC for the river segment downstream from the dam may not be appropriate since the source of the algae is upstream. Establishing an SSC downstream from the dam is not likely to achieve attainment of the phosphorus response indicator.
NR 119.04(2)(2) Biological metrics attained. A more stringent SSC may be appropriate even if a waterbody is below its statewide phosphorus criterion and it attains its phosphorus response indicators and biological assessment thresholds if it is demonstrated that a more stringent SSC than the statewide phosphorus criterion is necessary to maintain attainment of any of these indicators and the level necessary can be demonstrated through modeling. NR 119.04 NoteNote: For example, certain impounded flowing waters with a statewide phosphorus criterion of 100 ug/L may fit in this category if the ambient concentration of the waterbody is below the statewide criterion but concentrations approaching 100 ug/L would be too high to support recreation and aquatic life.
NR 119.04 HistoryHistory: CR 19-093: cr. Register September 2022 No. 801, eff. 10-1-22. NR 119.05NR 119.05 Methods for determining an SSC. An SSC shall be developed using one of the following methods: NR 119.05(1)(1) SSC based on ambient phosphorus concentration. For cases under s. NR 119.03 (1) when it is demonstrated that a less stringent SSC is appropriate because biological metrics are attained, the department may set the SSC at a concentration not to exceed a flowing water’s median ambient concentration, or a lake or reservoir’s mean ambient phosphorus concentration. If the weather-controlled total phosphorus concentration can be determined for the waterbody, this value may be used as the ambient phosphorus concentration. NR 119.05 NoteNote: The SSC is set at the waterbody’s median or mean ambient concentration (or weather-controlled phosphorus concentration) because the ambient concentration is deemed to be protective of designated uses if the waterbody attains its phosphorus response indicators and biological assessment thresholds at current concentrations.
NR 119.05(2)(a)(a) Modeling analysis. If a statistical or modeling analysis demonstrates that attaining a phosphorus concentration higher or lower than the statewide phosphorus criterion will attain a waterbody’s suspended chlorophyll a phosphorus response indicators specified in s. NR 102.60 (2) and (3), and the department initiates rulemaking to establish an SSC, the department shall propose an SSC at the modeled phosphorus concentration expected to attain the applicable indicators. The analysis shall be conducted following requirements specified in s. NR 119.06 (4) (b). NR 119.05 NoteNote: Modeling demonstrations under this subsection do not require modeling of biological communities such as fish, aquatic insect, or aquatic plant communities because, while predictive modeling is well-established for chlorophyll a concentrations, there are no widely-accepted modeling approaches that predict community-scale responses of fish, aquatic insect, or aquatic plant communities to variation in phosphorus concentrations with a high degree of precision.
NR 119.05(2)(b)(b) Use of natural background phosphorus concentrations. An SSC may be set no lower than a waterbody’s natural background phosphorus concentration if the background concentration can be determined. The natural background concentration may be estimated using the concentration for similar nearby waterbodies with minimal human impacts or other methods approved by the department. For natural lakes, the background concentration may be determined from a sediment core using paleolimnological methods. NR 119.05 NoteNote: Natural background phosphorus concentrations can be inferred from diatoms deposited in the sediment prior to significant impacts from Euro-American settlement, circa 1850s but variable across the state.
NR 119.05(3)(3) Alternative methods. An alternative method for setting an SSC may be used in cases that are outside of those described in ss. NR 119.03 to 119.04, when methods in subs. (1) to (2) are not appropriate or feasible, or to consider alternative or additional metrics. An SSC based on an alternative method may be approved if the department and U.S. EPA determine that the SSC is protective of the designated uses of the waterbody and downstream waters under s. NR 119.06 (6). NR 119.05 HistoryHistory: CR 19-093: cr. Register September 2022 No. 801, eff. 10-1-22; correction in (2) made under s. 13.92 (4) (b) 7., Stats., Register September 2022 No. 801. NR 119.06NR 119.06 Minimum requirements for an SSC submittal. Any person may submit a request to the department to review a proposed SSC for a waterbody or waterbody segment. The department may also develop an SSC through rulemaking absent any request. A person submitting the request is responsible for developing the proposed SSC, including conducting monitoring and modeling if needed. An SSC request submittal shall contain all of the following: NR 119.06(1)(1) SSC study area. The submittal shall contain identification of all waterbodies and segments within the SSC study area. The SSC study area includes all waterbodies and segments for which monitoring data are needed to determine whether a proposed SSC would be protective of designated uses. The study area is determined as follows: NR 119.06(1)(a)(a) For any SSC on an isolated waterbody such as a seepage lake, the isolated waterbody may comprise the entire SSC study area. At least one monitoring site within the waterbody is required. NR 119.06(1)(b)(b) For a more stringent SSC on a flowing water system, a single waterbody or segment may comprise the SSC study area. In this case, at least one monitoring site within the waterbody is required. A larger study area may also be established. NR 119.06(1)(c)(c) For a less stringent SSC on a flowing water system, the study area shall include monitoring sites on all of the following upstream and downstream waters:
