Chapter 281

281.36(3n)(b)1. 1. The direct impacts of the proposed project to wetland functional values.

281.36(3n)(b)2. 2. The cumulative impacts attributable to the proposed project that may occur to wetland functional values based on past impacts or reasonably anticipated impacts caused by similar projects in the area affected by the project.

281.36(3n)(b)3. 3. Potential secondary impacts of the proposed project to wetland functional values.

281.36(3n)(b)4. 4. The impact on functional values resulting from the mitigation that is required under sub. (3r).

281.36(3n)(b)5. 5. The net positive or negative environmental impact of the proposed project.

281.36(3n)(c) (c) Standards for issuing permits. The department shall make a finding that a proposed project causing a discharge is in compliance with water quality standards and that a wetland individual permit may be issued if the department determines that all of the following apply:

281.36(3n)(c)1. 1. The proposed project represents the least environmentally damaging practicable alternative taking into consideration practicable alternatives that avoid wetland impacts.

281.36(3n)(c)2. 2. All practicable measures to minimize the adverse impacts to wetland functional values will be taken.

281.36(3n)(c)3. 3. The proposed project will not result in significant adverse impact to wetland functional values, in significant adverse impact to water quality, or in other significant adverse environmental consequences.

281.36(3n)(d) (d) Mitigation required.

281.36(3n)(d)1. 1. Except as provided in subd. 2., the department shall require mitigation under the program established under sub. (3r) for wetland individual permits it issues under this subsection and for a discharge that is exempt from permitting requirements under sub. (4n) (b) that affects more than 10,000 square feet of wetland or under sub. (4n) (c) that affects more than 1.5 acres of wetland. This subsection does not entitle an applicant to a wetland individual permit or any other approval in exchange for conducting mitigation.

281.36(3n)(d)2. 2. If the department issues a wetland individual permit under sub. (3m) to a public utility, as defined in s. 196.01 (5), or a cooperative association organized under ch. 185 for the purpose of producing or furnishing heat, light, water, or power to its members only, the department may not require mitigation under the program established under sub. (3r) unless the discharge authorized by the wetland individual permit will result in a permanent fill of more than 10,000 square feet of wetland.

281.36(3p) (3p) Notice requirements; wetland individual permits.

281.36(3p)(a) (a) The department shall establish procedures for providing notices of pending applications and notices of public informational hearings to be provided under sub. (3m) and notices of administrative hearings under sub. (3q). The procedures shall require all of the following:

281.36(3p)(a)1. 1. That the notice be published as a class 1 notice under ch. 985.

281.36(3p)(a)2. 2. That the notice be provided to any person or group upon request of the person or group.

281.36(3p)(a)3. 3. That the notice be published on the department’s Internet website.

281.36(3p)(b) (b) The department shall prescribe the form and content of notices of pending applications and notices of public informational hearings to be provided under sub. (3m) and notices of administrative hearings under sub. (3q). Each notice shall include all of the following information:

281.36(3p)(b)1. 1. The name and address of the applicant.

281.36(3p)(b)2. 2. A brief description of the discharge that requires the permit and the project that includes the discharge.

281.36(3p)(b)3. 3. For a notice of a public informational hearing, the time, date, and location of the hearing.

281.36(3p)(b)4. 4. For a notice of pending application and a notice of a public informational hearing, a brief, precise, easily understandable, plain-language description of the discharge and information indicating where the pending application may be viewed on the department’s Internet website.

281.36(3p)(b)5. 5. For a notice of complete application and a notice of a public informational hearing, a statement of the tentative determination of the department on the permit.

281.36(3p)(b)6. 6. For a notice of complete application and a notice of public informational hearing, a brief description of the procedures for the formulation of final determinations, including a description of the comment period required under sub. (3m) (j).

281.36(3p)(c) (c) For the purpose of determining the date on which notice is provided under this subsection, the date of the notice shall be the date on which the department first publishes the notice on its Internet website.

281.36(3p)(d) (d)

281.36(3p)(d)1m. 1m. The department may delegate the department’s requirement to provide notice under sub. (3m) in the manner specified in par. (a) 1. and 2. by doing any of the following:

281.36(3p)(d)1m.a. a. Requiring that the applicant for the permit provide by publication, mailing, or other distribution one or more of the notices.

281.36(3p)(d)1m.b. b. Requiring that the applicant for the permit pay for the publication, mailing, or any other distribution costs of providing one or more of the notices.

281.36(3p)(d)2m. 2m. If, under subd. 1m., the department delegates to an applicant the requirement to provide notice under sub. (3m) by publishing a class 1 notice under ch. 985, the applicant may in lieu of publishing the class 1 notice request that the department publish the class 1 notice. The department shall charge the applicant a fee for publishing the class 1 notice in an amount that equals the average cost to the department for publishing under this chapter class 1 notices under ch. 985.

281.36(3q) (3q) Administrative and judicial review.

281.36(3q)(a) (a) Definition. In this subsection, “applicant” means any person applying for a wetland individual permit under this section or any person who has been issued such a permit under this section.

281.36(3q)(b) (b) Request for administrative review. Any interested person may file a petition with the department for administrative review within 30 days after any of the following decisions given by the department:

281.36(3q)(b)1. 1. The issuance, denial, or modification of any wetland individual permit issued under this section.

281.36(3q)(b)2. 2. The imposition of, or failure to impose, a condition on any wetland individual permit issued under this section.

281.36(3q)(c) (c) Content of the petition. If the petitioner is not the applicant, the petition shall describe the petitioner’s objection to the wetland individual permit and shall contain all of the following:

281.36(3q)(c)1. 1. A description of the objection that is sufficiently specific to allow the department to determine which provisions of this section may be violated if the proposed discharge under the wetland individual permit is allowed to proceed.

281.36(3q)(c)2. 2. A description of the facts supporting the petition that is sufficiently specific to determine how the petitioner believes the discharge, as proposed, may result in a violation of the provisions of this section.

281.36(3q)(c)3. 3. A commitment by the petitioner to appear at the administrative hearing and present information supporting the petitioner’s objection.

281.36(3q)(d) (d) Stays.

281.36(3q)(d)1. 1. The discharge shall be stayed pending an administrative hearing under this subsection if the petition contains a request for the stay showing that a stay is necessary to prevent significant adverse impacts or irreversible harm to the environment.

281.36(3q)(d)2. 2. If a stay is requested under subd. 1., the stay shall be in effect until either the department denies the request for an administrative hearing or the hearing examiner determines that the stay is not necessary.

281.36(3q)(e) (e) Filings. The petitioner shall file a copy of the petition with the department. If the petitioner is not the applicant, the petitioner shall simultaneously provide a copy of the petition to the applicant. The applicant may file a response to the petition with the department. If the applicant files a response under this paragraph, it shall be filed within 15 days after the petition is filed.

281.36(3q)(f) (f) Action on petition.

281.36(3q)(f)1m. 1m. The department shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days after the petition is filed. The failure of the department to dispose of the petition within this 30-day period is a denial. The department shall deny the petition if any of the following applies:

281.36(3q)(f)1m.a. a. The petitioner is not the applicant, and the petition does not comply with the requirements of par. (c).

281.36(3q)(f)1m.b. b. The objection contained in the petition is not substantive. The department shall determine that an objection is substantive if the supporting facts contained in the objection appear to be substantially true and raise reasonable grounds to believe that the provisions of this section may be violated if the activity or project is undertaken.

281.36(3q)(f)3. 3. If the department denies the petition, the department shall send the petitioner the denial in writing, stating the reasons for the denial.

281.36(3q)(f)4. 4. If the department grants a petition under this subsection, the department shall refer the matter to the division of hearings and appeals in the department of administration within 15 days after granting the petition unless the petitioner and the applicant agree to an extension.

281.36(3q)(g) (g) Administrative hearing.

281.36(3q)(g)1. 1. An administrative hearing under this subsection shall be treated as a contested case under ch. 227.

281.36(3q)(g)2. 2. If a stay under par. (d) 1. is in effect, the hearing examiner shall, within 30 days after receipt of the referral under par. (f) 4., determine whether continuation of the stay is necessary to prevent significant adverse impacts or irreversible harm to the environment pending completion of the administrative hearing. The hearing examiner shall make the determination based on the request under par. (d) 1., any response from the applicant under par. (e), and any testimony at a public hearing or any public comments. The determination shall be made without a hearing.

281.36(3q)(g)3. 3. An administrative hearing under this subsection shall be completed within 90 days after receipt of the referral of the petition under par. (f) 4., unless all parties agree to an extension of that period. In addition, a hearing examiner may grant a one-time extension for the completion of the hearing of up to 60 days on the motion of any party and a showing of good cause demonstrating extraordinary circumstances justifying an extension.

281.36(3q)(g)4. 4. Notwithstanding s. 227.44 (1), the department shall provide a notice of the administrative hearing at least 30 days before the date of the hearing to all of the following:

281.36(3q)(g)4.a. a. The applicant.

281.36(3q)(g)4.b. b. Each petitioner, if other than the applicant.

281.36(3q)(g)4.c. c. Any other persons required to receive notice as provided under sub. (3p).

281.36(3q)(g)5. 5. In an administrative hearing under this subsection, the petitioner shall proceed first with the presentation of evidence and shall have the burden of proof.

281.36(3q)(h) (h) Judicial review.

281.36(3q)(h)1. 1. Any person whose substantial interest is affected by a decision of the department under par. (b) 1. or 2. may commence an action in circuit court to review that decision.

281.36(3q)(h)2. 2. Any party aggrieved by a decision of the hearing examiner under par. (g) may commence an action in circuit court to review that decision.

281.36(3r) (3r) Mitigation; in lieu fee subprogram.

281.36(3r)(a) (a) The department shall establish a mitigation program that applies only to the issuance of wetland individual permits and, with respect to a discharge that is exempt from permitting requirements under sub. (4n) (b) that affects more than 10,000 square feet of wetland or under sub. (4n) (c) that affects more than 1.5 acres of wetland, the portion of the affected wetland that exceeds 10,000 square feet or 1.5 acres, respectively. Under the mitigation program, subject to par. (am), the department shall allow mitigation to be accomplished by any of the following methods:

281.36(3r)(a)1. 1.

281.36(3r)(a)1.a. a. Except as provided in subd. 1. b. and par. (ag), purchasing credits from a mitigation bank located in the same HUC 8 as the wetland impacted by the discharge.

281.36(3r)(a)1.b. b. Except as provided in subd. 1. c. and par. (ag), if credits are not available to be purchased as provided under subd. 1. a., credits may be purchased from a mitigation bank within the same bank service area as the wetland impacted by the discharge.

281.36(3r)(a)1.c. c. Except as provided in par. (ag), if credits are not available to be purchased as provided under subd. 1. b., credits may be purchased from a mitigation bank in the same basin as the wetland impacted by the discharge.

281.36(3r)(a)2. 2. Participating in the in lieu fee subprogram under par. (e).

281.36(3r)(a)3. 3. Completing mitigation within the same watershed or within one-half mile of the site of the discharge.

281.36(3r)(ag) (ag) The department may, in consultation with the U.S. army corps of engineers, allow credits to be purchased from a different mitigation bank than the one prescribed under par. (a) 1. or allow mitigation to be done through the in lieu fee subprogram rather than by purchasing credits from a mitigation bank if the department determines it would better serve natural resource goals, such as retaining flood water, improving or restoring wildlife habitat, or more closely matching the impacted wetland type. The department may also consider economic factors when making this determination only if the HUC 8 has one approved mitigation bank and that bank is charging a price for credits in that watershed that is in excess of 150 percent of the price of a credit in that watershed under the in lieu fee subprogram.

281.36(3r)(am) (am) For a discharge that is exempt from permitting requirements under sub. (4n) (b) or (c), any off-site mitigation, including any mitigation conducted by a mitigation bank or under the in lieu fee subprogram, shall be completed within the same compensation search area, as defined by the department by rule, as the discharge.

281.36(3r)(b) (b) Under the mitigation program, mitigation as specified in par. (a) 1. and participation in the in lieu fee subprogram shall be the preferred types of mitigation.

281.36(3r)(c) (c) The department shall establish a system of service areas for the mitigation banks under the mitigation program that is geographically based on the locations of the major watersheds in the state. The system shall be consistent with federal regulations.

281.36(3r)(cm) (cm) Before entering into an agreement with a sponsor of a mitigation bank to establish such a bank or before otherwise approving a mitigation bank, the department shall provide written notice that a mitigation bank may be established. The notice shall be given to each city, village, town, and county in which each proposed mitigation bank site will be located. Each city, village, town, and county receiving the notice shall be given an opportunity to submit comments regarding the establishment of the mitigation bank. The notice shall contain all of the following information:

281.36(3r)(cm)1. 1. The name of the sponsor of the proposed mitigation bank.

281.36(3r)(cm)2. 2. A brief description of the mitigation bank and all of its bank sites.

281.36(3r)(cm)3. 3. A date after which the department will not accept comments from the affected cities, villages, towns, or counties.

281.36(3r)(cm)4. 4. An address to which any comments shall be submitted.

281.36(3r)(d) (d)

281.36(3r)(d)1. 1. The department shall establish under the mitigation program mitigation ratios that are consistent, to the greatest extent possible, with the federal regulations that apply to mitigation and mitigation banks but, unless subd. 2. applies, the minimum ratio shall be at least 1.2 acres for each acre affected by the discharge.

281.36(3r)(d)2. 2. For mitigation that occurs within the same watershed in which the discharge is located or within one-half mile of the site of the discharge, the ratio established by the department shall equal 90 percent of the ratio that would apply if the mitigation were to occur outside the watershed or were to occur one-half mile or more from the site of the discharge, but the ratio established under this subdivision may be no less than 1.2 acres for each acre affected by the discharge.

281.36(3r)(e) (e) As part of the mitigation program established under par. (a), the department shall establish an in lieu fee subprogram, under which payments are made to the department or another entity for the purposes of restoring, enhancing, creating, or preserving wetlands or other water resource features. The subprogram must be approved by the U.S. army corps of engineers. The department shall establish requirements for calculating the in lieu fee payments. Under the in lieu fee subprogram, the wetlands that benefit from the subprogram may be open to the public for hunting, fishing, trapping, cross-country skiing, or hiking or any combination thereof. In determining approved mitigation projects that benefit from the subprogram, the department shall, to the extent practicable, ensure that there is no net loss of public access to wetlands. If the wetlands that benefit from the subprogram are open to the public, the department may establish reasonable restrictions on the use of the land by the public in order to protect public safety or to protect a unique plant or animal community. The subprogram shall be consistent with federal regulations.

281.36(3t) (3t) Rules for mitigation. The department shall promulgate rules to establish a process for the mitigation program under sub. (3r). The rules shall address all of the following:

281.36(3t)(a) (a) Requirements for the analysis of practicable alternatives that is included in an application for a wetland individual permit under sub. (3m) (b).

281.36(3t)(b) (b) The conditions under which credits may be purchased from a mitigation bank to comply with the mitigation program under sub. (3r).

281.36(3t)(c) (c) Enforcement of requirements under the mitigation program under sub. (3r) that apply to mitigation projects and mitigation banks.

281.36(3t)(d) (d) Baseline studies of wetlands that will be affected by the discharges and of sites for mitigation projects.

281.36(3t)(e) (e) Plan and design requirements for mitigation projects and mitigation bank sites, which shall include requirements for relating the design of a mitigation project or a mitigation bank site to the hydrology of the watershed in which a mitigation project or mitigation bank site is located.

281.36(3t)(f) (f) Standards for comparing wetlands that will be restored, enhanced, created, or preserved as a mitigation project or at a mitigation bank site to the wetlands that will be adversely affected by discharges, including all of the following: